City of Bots


For years I've been hearing people say the internet is mostly bots, usually with some amount of levity. Given how quickly GPT has improved though, I think we're actually about to hit a tipping point where convincing, human-like bots will outnumber humans on the internet by at least an order of magnitude... probably more.

Think about all the incentives there are for people to add bot users to the internet:

  • Influencers will buy bot fans/followers/replyguys to make themselves look more popular
  • Website operators will use bots to augment their userbase, hoping to "seed" it with activity
  • Political parties and politicians will recruit bots to push their narratives and bolster their support
  • Trolls will use bots to harrass their enemies
  • Companies will use bots as social media customer support agents
  • Marketing agencies will use bots to support their "viral marketing" campaigns

Even real, actual human internet users will use bots to write content for them to save time or be more prolific, meaning they will be part bots too.

Of course there have always been bots. That's why we have CAPTCHAs, right? So what has changed?

The bots of yesterday were dumb. They weren't good at comprehension, they had limited capacity for creativity. They were simple programs written by humans. They got stumped by a CAPTCHA.

The bots of tomorrow are massive neural networks, more intelligent than the average person. They are capable of both interpreting and generating text, images, videos, and sounds. They will be indiscernible from human users, whom they will vastly outnumber. The internet will become a city of bots, and humans will become a minority.

Even video platforms like TikTok and Pornhub will be inundated with deepfake videos. The friction and cost of generating fake human-like content will exponentially decrease.

Lee Sedol famously quit playing Go after DeepMind's AlphaGo system crushed him 4-1 in 2016. "Even if I become the number one, there is an entity that cannot be defeated" he was quoted as saying. By all accounts, Hassabis' team ruined the game for Lee.

Very soon, it will be impossible to tell who's real and who's not online. This might lead to people actually using the internet a lot less. The appeal may be lost when we all realize that we're mostly just interacting with computers. What will be the point?


> Very soon, it will be impossible to tell who's real and who's not online. It reminded me of a Japanese anime called Time of Eve that explores similar concepts of human-android interaction and the blurring of the lines between the two. The anime is set in a future where androids have become an integral part of daily life, and follows a group of characters as they navigate the complexities of living with androids that are becoming increasingly human-like. It raises interesting questions about what it means to be human and the role that technology plays in our lives. I can't quite remember if it's a must-watch, but the series definitely left an impact on me due to its thought-provoking exploration of the relationship between humans and androids.
Thanks for the comment Seve. I'll check out that anime. I hope you've been well.

Add Comment

optional, will not be published
"Dream only a dream if work don't follow it"